To get to Spanish Wells, you want to fly into the North Eleuthera airport (ELH). There are direct flights to ELH from Nassau (NAS), Miami (MIA), Atlanta (ATL), and Fort Lauderdale (FLL). On Saturdays, there is a direct flight from Orlando (MCO).
You can also take the ferry from Nassau to Spanish Wells.
United / Silver Airways usually has several daily flights to ELH via Fort Lauderdale. American Airlines usually has one daily flight from Miami. Delta has flights to ELH from Atlanta several days per week. And Pineapple Air has several flights per day from Nassau (NAS) to ELH.
It takes about 30 minutes to get from the airport to the house. Here's how you do it:
1.) Take a 10-15 minute taxi from the airport to the Spanish Wells water taxi.
2.) The water taxi is a 5 minute boat ride and usually runs every 15 minutes.
3.) Rent a golf cart. Harbourside Rentals is right where the water taxi drops you off.
4.) It's a two minute golf cart ride from Harbourside Rentals to the house, about 1/4 mile. Or you can walk from the water taxi drop off to the house instead of renting a golf cart. It's a 10 minute walk. Or, email or call our house manager Andre and he can probably give you a ride to the house.
The house is on the northside beach at 11th Street. From the water taxi, go west on the island's main street (Leo Pinder St) and turn right on 11th. It's the lime green house at the end of 11th on the left.
You can contact Pinder's Taxi if you would like to arrange for transportation from the airport to the water taxi ahead of time. Calvin Pinder's cell number is 242-359-7135. The people who run Pinder Taxi also run the water taxi so if you are arriving late in the evening, check with Pinder Taxi about the exact water taxi hours. The taxi and water taxi schedules revolve around the ELH flight schedules, so you should have no problem getting a taxi and water taxi to/from the airport regardless of departure and arrival time. Pinder Taxi charges $15 per person to get from the airport to Spanish Wells via their van and water taxi boat.
If you are just visiting Spanish Wells, there is really no reason to have a car on the island. A golf cart or bicycle is a much better option.
Note that when leaving Spanish Wells for the airport, you should board the water taxi for Eleuthera at least two hours before your flight's departure. And here's an ELH airport tip: check in as soon as you get to the airport and then wait at the cafe and liquor store across the street from the airport. The airport waiting room is really tiny. Airport personnel will come over to the cafe and let you know when it's time to board.
If you are leaving on an early flight (there's a 7:20 AM flight to Nassau most days), there is a 6:00 AM water taxi that will get you to Eleuthera in time to catch the flight. Call Pinder taxi to confirm that it's running and they'll have a taxi waiting for you to take you to the airport.
If you are interested in a charter flight to/from any of the islands in the Bahamas, here is a link to Bahamas Hoppers.
And here is a map of Spanish Wells: